Sazeracs and crawfish
April 23rd, 2008 by everettI went to the first of my annual crawfish boils this last weekend. My boiling pot and burner arrived from Amazon the day before, so I took it along in case we wanted to use two. We did, and I am amazed at the difference between the older, 35,000 btu burner we used and my new 105,000 btu jet burner. 120 pounds of crawfish went pretty quick with two pots going.
Each boil, I pick a cocktail to make. There’s been the Mexican Martini, one year, and Mojitos, another. This year, I opted for the Sazerac, since we had some good friends coming in from New Orleans. I’ve tried a couple of recipes, but the best, by far, is Jeffrey Morgenthaler’s Sazerac:
Fill an Old-Fashioned glass with ice and water, and set aside to chill. Once cold, drain ice water and rinse with Herbsaint.
In a 16-oz mixing glass, combine:
- 1 sugar cube
-or-
¼ oz simple syrup - 4 dashes Peychaud’s bitters
- 1 dash Angostura bitters
- Small splash water
Muddle together until sugar cube is dissolved (skip this step if using simple syrup, obviously)
Add:
- 2 oz rye
Fill mixing glass with ice and stir contents until well-chilled. Strain into Herbsaint-rinsed Old Fashioned glass. Twist lemon peel over drink to express oils, and discard peel.
If you’re new to this, there’s a couple of things to note. You can get a very bad excuse for a Sazerac if you don’t follow the directions closely. This is a strong drink. You’re basically drinking rye whiskey with some flavoring from the bitter, lemon, and Herbsaint.
Speaking of Herbsaint, don’t do more than rinse the glass with it. The flavor will be overpowering and you’ll ruin your drink if you go nuts with the Herbsaint.
Note the whiskey used. Rye whiskey, not bourbon. Different whiskey, different flavor - don’t substitute here. Jeffrey prefers the Buffalo Trace Sazerac rye, but I opted for Wild Turkey’s rye since my local liquor store doesn’t carry Buffalo Trace’s whiskey. I thought the Wild Turkey made a great cocktail.
Be sure to check out Jeffrey’s do’s and don’ts of Sazeracs, then go forth and make one!






